Context:
The Ministry of Railways provided ₹10 lakh ex-gratia payments to the families of 18 deceased in the New Delhi Railway Station stampede, distributing the amount entirely in cash. This highlights the role of ex-gratia payments as a relief measure in emergencies.
What is Ex-Gratia?
Ex-gratia is a payment made as a goodwill gesture without any legal obligation. It is typically granted by the government, corporations, or institutions to provide financial assistance in cases of:
- Accidents (railway, road, or industrial mishaps)
- Natural disasters (earthquakes, floods, cyclones)
- Death or injury during public service (armed forces, police personnel)
- Special cases requiring financial aid (COVID-19 ex-gratia relief)
Ex-gratia payments aim to provide immediate relief and support to affected individuals or their families but do not replace legally mandated compensation.
Legal Framework Governing Ex-Gratia Payments
Unlike compensation, ex-gratia payments are not governed by any specific statutory law. The guidelines for ex-gratia relief are determined by the relevant ministry or department.
- Railway Ex-Gratia Payments: Governed by the Railway Accidents and Untoward Incidents (Compensation) Rules, 1990.
- Disaster Relief: Provided under the State Disaster Response Fund (SDRF) and National Disaster Response Fund (NDRF) guidelines.
- Military & Police Service: Special ex-gratia is given to families of personnel who die in action, as per defense or home ministry policies.
- Pandemic-Related Payments: The government announced ex-gratia relief for families of COVID-19 victims under the Disaster Management Act, 2005.
Procedure for Ex-Gratia Payments
- Verification of Identity:
- Aadhaar card, legal heir certificate, and death certificate of the deceased (if applicable).
- Approval by Authorities:
- The competent government authority reviews and sanctions the payment.
- Disbursal of Funds:
- Payments are made in cash (for immediate relief) or via bank transfer (for final compensation).
Modes of Ex-Gratia Payment
- Cash Payment: Allowed for immediate assistance, particularly in railway accidents (up to ₹50,000).
- Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT): Aadhaar-linked bank transfer for accountability and transparency.
- Cheque/NEFT: Preferred for larger amounts to ensure traceability.
Difference Between Ex-Gratia and Compensation
| Aspect | Ex-Gratia | Compensation |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Voluntary, goodwill-based | Legal obligation |
| Purpose | Immediate relief | Compensation for loss or damage |
| Legal Basis | No legal requirement | Defined under law |
| Approval | By government or officials | Decided by courts or statutes |
Challenges in Ex-Gratia Payments
- Lack of Uniformity: Different ministries and state governments follow varying guidelines.
- Delayed Processing: Bureaucratic delays often slow down the disbursal process.
- Limited Legal Recourse: Since ex-gratia is not a legal right, beneficiaries cannot challenge the amount in court.
- Mode of Payment Issues: Cash payments, while immediate, can lead to misuse or lack of accountability.
Way Forward
- Standardized Policy: Establishing a uniform ex-gratia payment framework across sectors.
- Fast-Track Approvals: Using technology (e-KYC, Aadhaar authentication) to expedite payments.
- Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) Expansion: Ensuring all payments go through official banking channels for transparency.
- Awareness Campaigns: Educating citizens about their rights and eligibility for ex-gratia relief.
Conclusion
Ex-gratia payments serve as a crucial financial relief tool in times of crisis, offering quick assistance to affected individuals. While not legally binding, they provide essential support in emergencies. Strengthening governance mechanisms, ensuring faster disbursal, and promoting transparency can improve the efficiency of ex-gratia relief in India.
MCQs on Ex-Gratia Payments
What is the primary purpose of ex-gratia payments?
a) Compensation for financial loss
b) Voluntary financial aid without legal obligation
c) Mandatory government compensation
d) Tax rebate for citizensAnswer: b) Voluntary financial aid without legal obligation
Which of the following is NOT a common situation for ex-gratia payments?
a) Accidents and natural disasters
b) Regular salary payments
c) Public service deaths
d) Pandemic-related reliefAnswer: b) Regular salary payments
Under which act were ex-gratia payments provided for COVID-19 victims?
a) The Epidemic Diseases Act, 1897
b) The Disaster Management Act, 2005
c) The Railway Compensation Act, 1990
d) The Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act, 2003Answer: b) The Disaster Management Act, 2005
Which ministry determines the ex-gratia amount for railway accidents?
a) Ministry of Finance
b) Ministry of Railways
c) Ministry of Home Affairs
d) Ministry of LabourAnswer: b) Ministry of Railways
What is the preferred mode of payment for large ex-gratia amounts?
a) Cash payments
b) Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT)
c) Gift vouchers
d) Stock market investmentsAnswer: b) Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT)
Mains Practice Question
"Ex-gratia payments play a vital role in providing financial relief during emergencies. Analyze their effectiveness, challenges, and suggest measures to enhance their transparency and timely disbursal." (250 words).
Also Read:
No comments:
Post a Comment